Freshly Baked. Bold Flavors. As Seen on Fox News.
At Crumbly Bakery & Café, cookies are crafted with the same care, creativity, and premium standards as our celebrated cakes.
Baked fresh in New York in small batches, our cookies deliver luxury texture, rich flavor, and unforgettable indulgence — the kind that turns a simple treat into a full experience.
Proudly As Seen on Fox News, Crumbly NYC has become known for elevated desserts that blend classic comfort with modern bakery excellence.
Our Signature Cookie Flavors
Each Crumbly cookie is handcrafted using premium ingredients and perfected recipes. Here’s what makes every flavor special:
🍪 Chocolate Chip
A timeless classic done the Crumbly way.
Golden-baked with crisp edges, a soft, gooey center, and generous chunks of rich chocolate. Comforting, indulgent, and impossible to resist.
🔥 S’mores
Inspired by the iconic campfire favorite.
A decadent blend of chocolate, marshmallow flavor, and buttery cookie dough — delivering nostalgic sweetness with a gourmet bakery finish.
❤️ Red Velvet
Velvety, soft, and subtly chocolatey.
This striking red cookie offers a delicate cocoa flavor with a smooth, tender crumb that feels both luxurious and indulgent.
🌾 Oatmeal Raisin
A refined take on a classic favorite.
Chewy oats paired with plump raisins and warm, comforting notes — perfectly balanced between wholesome and indulgent.
🥜 Peanut Butter
Rich, nutty, and deeply satisfying.
Smooth peanut butter flavor baked into a soft yet structured cookie, delivering bold taste without overwhelming sweetness.
🍫 Peanut Butter Chocolate
The ultimate flavor duo.
Creamy peanut butter meets rich chocolate in a perfectly balanced cookie that’s bold, indulgent, and intensely crave-worthy.
🧂 Salted Caramel
Sweet meets savory in perfect harmony.
Buttery caramel notes balanced with a touch of sea salt, creating a sophisticated cookie with depth and irresistible contrast.
🌈 M&M’s
Colorful, fun, and loaded with chocolate.
Soft cookie dough filled with crunchy candy-coated chocolates — playful, nostalgic, and perfect for all ages.
Why Customers Choose Crumbly Cookies?
Freshly baked daily in NYC
Premium ingredients, no shortcuts
Handcrafted for perfect texture and flavor
Ideal for gifting, events, and dessert tables
From a bakery featured on Fox News
Every batch reflects the same elevated standard you expect from Crumbly Bakery & Cafe.
A True New York Bakery Experience
Whether you’re indulging in a single favorite or ordering an assortment to share, Crumbly cookies offer a luxury bakery experience in every bite.
If you love our cakes, you’ll recognize the same craftsmanship here — and if this is your first taste of Crumbly, you’re about to discover why our desserts have earned national attention.
Order your Crumbly cookies today and experience the flavors everyone’s talking about.
