Custom Cakes

Create your dream cake with Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. We offer fully custom cakes in every style — heart cakes, vintage piping, character cakes, buttercream florals, themed designs, corporate cakes, and more. All handmade to order in New York City and personalized to your flavors, colors, and event details. Perfect for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and all special celebrations.

Beauty & The Beast Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different flavors & sizes

Black & White Cherry Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Bluey & Bingo Cake

Starts from — $140

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & colors

Cherry Bombshell Vintage Cake

Starts from — $165

Available in different flavors & sizes

Little Cherries Birthday Cake

Starts from — $100

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from $95

Available in different sizes & flavors

Starts from $160

Available in different sizes & flavors

Cookie Monster Cake

6", 3 Layers — $115

9", 3 Layers — $185

Starts from — $120

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Lavender Heart Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from $115

Available in different sizes

Air Jordan Cake

Starts from $115

Available in different sizes

Available in different flavors

Starts from $120

Available in different flavors & sizes

Construction Cake

Starts from $115

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from — $115

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & colors

Starts from — $120

Available in different sizes & colors

Flourless Chocolate Cake

PRE ORDERS ONLY

Available in different sizes

Starts from — $115

Available in different COLORS, sizes & flavors

Galaxy Space Cake

Starts from $120

Available in different sizes & flavors

Starts from $115

Available in different sizes & flavors

Frozen Cake 2.0

Starts from $120

Available in different sizes & flavors

Gender Reveal Cake

Starts from $45

Available in different flavors & sizes

Golden Bloom Celebration Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & flavors

Starts from $115

Available in different flavors & sizes

McQueen Pixar Car Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Mickey Mouse Clubhouse Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

Starts from — $120

Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier

Off the Cliff Cake

Starts from $105

Available in different sizes & flavors

Ombre/Drip Cake

Starts from $105

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & flavors

Taylor Swift – Life of A Show Girl Cake

Starts from — $105

Available in different flavors & sizes

Pastel Butterfly Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & flavors

Paw Patrol – Edible Characters

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & colors

Paw Patrol Cake

Starts from $115

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

Sesame Street – Pick your Character Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & colors

Sesame Street Cake

Starts from $120

Available in different sizes & flavors

Sports Fan Cake

Available in different flavors

Starts from $120

Available in different sizes

Taylor Swift – SWIFTIE Cake

Starts from — $140

Available in different flavors & sizes

Teddy Bear Cake

Starts from $110

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

THE “Pretty” Cake

Starts from — $105

Available in different flavors & sizes

The Cocoa Edition Vintage Cake

Starts from — $130

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from — $105

Available in different flavors & sizes

The “simple” Vintage Style Cake

Starts from $105

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

Starts from $115

Available in different sizes

The Bieber Birthday Cake with Cherries

Starts from — $130

Available in different flavors & sizes

The Disco Ball Vintage Cake

Starts from $135

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

The Elegant Artistry Cake

Starts from — $115

Available in different sizes & flavors

The Elegant Edition Vintage Cake

Starts from — $130

Available in different flavors & sizes

THE Fairytale Vintage Cake

Starts from $135

Available in different sizes & flavors

The Pink Edition Vintage Cake

Starts from — $130

Available in different flavors & sizes

THE Ultimate Vintage Style Cake

Starts from $135

Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes

Tini Bit Older Cake

Starts from $120

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from $115

Available in different flavors & sizes

Starts from $120

Available in different sizes

4", 3 Layers — $35

6” and 9” also available

4”, 3 Layers — $35

6” and 9” also available

Red Velvet Cake

4”, 3 Layers — $35

6” and 9” also available

4”, 3 Layers — $35

6” and 9” also available

4”, 3 Layers — $35

6” and 9” also available

Vegan Vanilla Cake

4”, 3 Layers — $45

6” and 9” also available

Looking for a custom design?

Create a Unique Cake

View Cake Gallery

Copyright © 2025 Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.