Warm. Gooey. Irresistibly Decadent.
The Nutella Cookie Pie from Crumbly Bakery & Café is where two beloved desserts meet — a rich, buttery cookie base filled with creamy Nutella® hazelnut spread, baked to golden perfection. Soft and gooey in the center with perfectly baked edges, this dessert delivers deep chocolate-hazelnut flavor in every indulgent bite.
Handcrafted in New York and proudly As Seen on Fox News, this pie is a Crumbly favorite for customers who want something comforting, bold, and unmistakably indulgent.
What Makes Our Nutella Cookie Pie Special
-
Thick, bakery-style cookie crust with golden edges
-
Generous Nutella® filling that stays rich and gooey
-
Perfect balance of sweetness and texture
-
Baked fresh in small batches
-
Made with premium ingredients, never shortcuts
It’s indulgent without being overwhelming — a dessert that feels luxurious, familiar, and deeply satisfying all at once.
Perfect for Any Occasion
Crumbly’s Nutella Cookie Pie is ideal for:
-
Celebrations and birthdays
-
Dinner parties and casual gatherings
-
Sharing with family and friends
-
Nutella lovers who want something truly special
Serve it warm for an extra decadent experience, or enjoy it at room temperature for rich, fudgy texture.
A Comfort Dessert, Elevated
This Nutella Cookie Pie reflects everything Crumbly stands for:
quality ingredients, generous portions, and desserts that feel made with care.
Baked fresh at Crumbly Bakery & Cafe, it carries the same craftsmanship and attention to detail that have earned Crumbly national recognition.
Order the Crumbly Nutella Cookie Pie today and experience the perfect fusion of cookie and pie in one unforgettable dessert. 🍪🍫
🥧 Explore Our Full Pie Collection
If you love our Nutella Cookie Pie, be sure to explore the rest of our handcrafted pies.
At Crumbly Bakery & Café, our pie collection includes a variety of classic favorites and indulgent specialties, all baked fresh in NYC with premium ingredients and signature Crumbly care.
From rich chocolate creations to comforting cookie-based pies, each dessert is crafted for balanced sweetness, perfect texture, and share-worthy indulgence.
👉 Explore all pies from Crumbly Bakery & Café and find the perfect dessert for your next celebration.
