A Colorful Classic Crafted in New York
The Sesame Street Cake is designed to bring warmth, color, and joyful childhood energy to your celebration.
Inspired by the friendly, playful world generations of kids adore, this cake features a bright, cheerful design that feels welcoming and fun. It’s vibrant without being overwhelming — the perfect centerpiece for birthdays filled with laughter, smiles, and sweet memories.
Handcrafted by the pastry artists at Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York, each Sesame Street Cake is baked fresh to order and finished entirely by hand. From the smooth buttercream base to the character-inspired decorative elements, every detail is created with care, precision, and creativity.
This is not a mass-produced kids cake.
It’s a timeless childhood celebration, made the Crumbly way.
Why the Sesame Street Cake Stands Out
This cake blends nostalgic joy with premium craftsmanship.
Each Sesame Street Cake features:
-
A classic character-inspired design kids instantly recognize
-
Bright, playful colors that photograph beautifully
-
Smooth, creamy buttercream for a clean, polished finish
-
High-quality ingredients selected for flavor and texture
At Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York, kids’ cakes are designed to feel joyful and thoughtfully made — so parents feel confident and kids feel excited.
Perfect for Sweet, Joyful Celebrations
The Sesame Street Cake is ideal for:
-
Kids’ birthday parties
-
Toddler and preschool celebrations
-
First birthdays and early milestones
-
Parents who want a fun, familiar theme with a premium finish
Available in multiple sizes to suit different party sizes. Please refer to the size and serving information below to select the best option for your celebration.
Craftsmanship Recognized Nationwide
Our custom cake designs have been recognized beyond New York City.
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York was proudly featured on Fox News Morning Show, highlighting the creativity and craftsmanship behind our cakes.
That same attention to detail goes into every Sesame Street Cake we create.
🎈🧸 Bright colors. Friendly faces.
A cake designed for happy childhood moments.
