Sports Cakes

Celebrate every win with our Sports Cakes, custom-designed and handcrafted at Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York. Whether it’s a birthday, team celebration, championship party, or a special milestone for a sports fan, our cakes are made to capture the excitement of the game and turn it into an unforgettable centerpiece.

From baseball and basketball to soccer, football, and custom sports themes, each cake is crafted with attention to detail, smooth buttercream finishes, and bold, clean designs that reflect the passion of the sport. Inside, you’ll find rich, flavorful layers made with fresh, high-quality ingredients — baked and assembled fresh to order.

Our sports cakes are perfect for kids, teens, and adults alike, making them a popular choice for birthdays, watch parties, team events, and celebrations where sports bring people together. Every design balances fun, creativity, and Crumbly’s signature craftsmanship, ensuring your cake looks just as impressive as it tastes.

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery has been featured on the Fox News Morning Show and recognized by Harper’s Bazaar as one of the 28 best desserts in New York City, making us a trusted choice for custom cakes across Manhattan and beyond.

If you’re looking for custom sports cakes in NYC that combine bold design, premium ingredients, and expert craftsmanship, our Sports Cakes collection delivers celebration-worthy results every time.

📍 Freshly made in New York. Designed to celebrate. Crafted with love.