The Baseball Cake is designed for true fans of the game — and for celebrations where passion, tradition, and joy take center stage.
Clean, playful, and instantly recognizable, this cake captures the spirit of baseball while maintaining a polished, well-crafted finish. It feels energetic without being messy, fun without feeling generic — the perfect centerpiece for sports lovers of all ages.
Handcrafted by the pastry artists at Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York, each Baseball Cake is baked fresh to order and finished entirely by hand. From its classic baseball-inspired design to its smooth buttercream detailing, every element is made with care and intention.
This is not a mass-produced sports cake.
It’s a celebration of the game — made with quality you can trust.
Available Flavors
The Baseball Cake is available in a variety of crowd-pleasing flavors, including:
-
Chocolate
-
Vanilla
-
Red Velvet
Each flavor is made using premium ingredients to ensure a rich, balanced taste that guests of all ages will enjoy.
Why the Baseball Cake Is a Fan Favorite
This cake blends classic sports energy with refined craftsmanship.
Each Baseball Cake features:
-
A clean, baseball-inspired design with polished detailing
-
Smooth buttercream finish for a premium look
-
High-quality ingredients selected for flavor and consistency
-
Handcrafted finishing that photographs beautifully
At Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York, themed cakes are never treated as shortcuts — every design receives the same attention as our luxury statement cakes.
Perfect for Sports-Filled Celebrations
The Baseball Cake is ideal for:
-
Kids’ and adult birthday parties
-
Baseball team celebrations
-
Sports-themed events
-
Anyone celebrating a love for the game
Available in multiple sizes to suit different party sizes. Please refer to the size and serving information below to select the best option for your event.
Craftsmanship Recognized Nationwide
Our custom cake designs have been recognized beyond New York City.
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery New York was proudly featured on Fox News Morning Show, highlighting the creativity and craftsmanship behind our cakes.
That same care and precision goes into every Baseball Cake we create.
⚾ Classic design. Crowd-pleasing flavors.
A cake made to celebrate the game.
