Custom Cakes

Create your dream cake with Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. We offer fully custom cakes in every style — heart cakes, vintage piping, character cakes, buttercream florals, themed designs, corporate cakes, and more. All handmade to order in New York City and personalized to your flavors, colors, and event details. Perfect for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and all special celebrations.

Vintage Gender Reveal Cake with ivory buttercream piping, pink and blue ribbon bows, and a Boy or Girl message by Crumbly Bakery NYC
🎀💙 Vintage Gender Reveal Cake
Made to Order
Available in multiple sizes with a hidden pink or blue reveal inside.
Golden Bloom Celebration Cake at CrumblyNYC
Golden Bloom Celebration Cake: Timeless Floral Elegance Crafted in New York
Available in different sizes & flavors
Minions Birthday Cake NYC with yellow buttercream, edible goggles, blue overalls, and custom birthday message by Crumbly.
Minions Birthday Cake NYC
Made to Order
Available in different sizes
SpongeBob Birthday Cake NYC with blue buttercream, edible SpongeBob and Patrick decorations, underwater details, and personalized birthday lettering by Crumbly.
SpongeBob Birthday Cake NYC
Made to Order
Available in different sizes
Toy Story Birthday Cake NYC featuring Woody, Buzz Lightyear, colorful handcrafted decorations, and personalized birthday details by Crumbly.
Toy Story Cake
Made to Order
Available in different sizes
Jungle Cake NYC
Jungle Cake – A Wild Celebration Crafted in New York
Available in different flavors & sizes
Safari Birthday Cake NYC with jungle animal decorations and personalized birthday details by Crumbly Cafe & Bakery
Safari Cake
Made to Order
Available in different flavors & sizes
McQueen Car Cake NYC
McQueen Pixar Car Cake
Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse Cake NYC
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse Cake
Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes
Moana Cake NYC
Moana Cake
Available in 6" 9" & 2-Tier
“Weenie Bit Older” Cake
Available in different sizes & flavors
Off the Cliff Cake NYC
Off the Cliff Cake
Available in different sizes & flavors
Sesame Street Character Cake NYC
Sesame Street – Pick your Character Cake
Available in different sizes & colors
Ombre/Drip Cake
Available in different COLORS, flavors & sizes
Roses Cake NYC by Crumbly NYC
Roses Cake: Romantic Floral Elegance Crafted in New York
Available in different sizes & flavors
Life of a Show Girl Cake NYC
Taylor Swift – Life of A Show Girl Cake
Available in different flavors & sizes
Vintage Chocolate Cake NYC by Crumbly Cafe & Bakery featuring rich cocoa-colored buttercream, romantic vintage piping, and elegant decorative borders
The Cocoa Edition – Vintage Chocolate Cake
Available in different flavors & sizes
Available in different sizes
Paw Patrol Birthday Cake NYC by Crumbly Cafe & Bakery featuring edible Chase, Marshall, and Rocky character toppers with blue buttercream and colorful decorations.
Paw Patrol Cake – Edible Characters
Made to Order
Available in different sizes
Butterfly Cake NYC by Crumbly Cafe & Bakery featuring pastel buttercream and delicate butterfly decorations
Pastel Butterfly Cake
Made to Order
Available in different sizes & flavors
Sesame Street Cake NYC
Sesame Street Cake
Available in different sizes & flavors

Looking for a custom design?

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

Copyright © 2026 Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.

Delivery Info
We offer delivery to the following zip codes. There is no minimum order total for delivery.
Cost
Zip Codes
$10.00
10022, 10128
$20.00
10021, 10065, 10075, 10028, 10021, 10017, 10174, 10016
$25.00
10009, 10010, 10011, 10001, 10018, 10036, 10029, 10025
$25.00
10038, 10004, 10007, 10013, 10014, 10036, 10027, 10019, 10112, 10026, 10030
$30.00
10023, 10069, 10024, 10031, 10032, 10033, 10106
$35.00
11101, 11109, 11102, 11103, 11105, 11106, 11222, 11211, 11249, 10002, 10003, 10005, 10006, 10012, 10034, 10035, 10037, 10039, 11205, 11206
$40.00
11373, 10280, 10282, 11201, 11215, 11231
Let's Answer Your Questions

Orders must be placed a minimum of 48-72 hours in advance. Availability may vary during holidays and peak seasons.

Yes! We specialize in custom cakes. Feel free to browse our most popular customizable cakes, or submit a custom cake inquiry form with as many details as possible if you don’t see exactly what you’re looking for. Our team will review your request and follow up with next steps.

Our classic flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate, Funfetti, Red Velvet, Lemon, Strawberry and Oreo. Seasonal and specialty flavors may also be available.

We’re happy to use inspiration images as design guidance. Please note that each cake is handmade, and we cannot guarantee an identical replica.

Yes! Many of our cakes can be made gluten-free and/or vegan. Availability may vary by flavor and design, so we recommend including your dietary preferences when submitting your inquiry or giving us a call to confirm options.

We’re happy to accommodate certain dietary requests whenever possible. While we take care in our preparation, our kitchen is not nut-free and we cannot guarantee the absence of allergens. Please contact us with any specific concerns.

Yes, delivery is available within NYC for an additional fee. Pickup is also available at our Midtown East and Upper East Side locations.

Rush orders may be possible depending on availability and may be subject to an additional fee. Please contact us directly to inquire.

Because all orders are made to order, payments are non-refundable. Changes may be accommodated with advance notice, subject to availability.
Select a Location
Select one of our bakeries below to order from our current, in-stock food and beverage items. Please note our Inventory changes throughout the day.